No Support Needed Octagonal Compression Spring

No Support Needed Octagonal Compression Spring

Boost
36
42
18
GIF

Print Profile(3)

All
P1P
P1S
X1
X1 Carbon
X1E
A1

Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
Designer
19 min
1 plate
4.0(5)

0.12mm layer, 5 walls, 0% infill
0.12mm layer, 5 walls, 0% infill
Designer
30 min
1 plate
1.8(4)

A1 Mini profile with raft
A1 Mini profile with raft
20 min
1 plate

Boost
36
42
18
0
153
115
Released

Description

A octagonal spring that can be printed on its side without support. A proof of concept that aims to solve the problem of breaking small springs when trying to remove support from it.

Comment & Rating (18)

Please fill in your opinion
(0/5000)

Came off the brim and failed. It was with double brim width compared to default (so 10mm instead of 5mm). That was bout 40%/50% of the print when it happened, maybe it can finish but if you can think of ways to make it more reliable it would be great.
The designer has replied
1
Reply
I could make it hexagonal or even rectangular to give it more contact to the bed but I chose the octagonal shape since it's as close to a regular spring as I can get while still having the bare minimal amount of contact to the bed needed. If you want to try a hexagonal or rectangular one, I will be happy to post it for you.
0
Reply
Replying to @nokiri :
I am happy to test print either. I think the octagonal could finish, just not reliably enough
1
Reply
Replying to @macjabko :
I've uploaded a hexagonal one and was able to print even without brim. Give it a try and put up a brim if it's not printing reliably.
0
Reply
failed 2 times when printed 3 copies
The designer has replied
1
Reply
maybe make a bigger brim
0
Reply
Print Profile
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
very cool
1
Reply
Print Profile
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
there isn't enough surface area for it to stick so I recommend glue but it's super nice to fidget with
1
Reply
Print Profile
0.12mm layer, 5 walls, 0% infill
just got a spaghetti mess
1
Reply
Print Profile
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
After several tests, it sometimes prints and works as a spring, sometimes pops off the bed. So not bad overall!
1
Reply
Print Profile
0.12mm layer, 5 walls, 0% infill
Strength Issue:spring broke in multiple prints and materials with very little pressure applied
The designer has replied
1
Reply
I really should revisit this soon… But meanwhile, try to print with a brim and use pla+ since those are usually more flexible.
(Edited)
0
Reply
Print Profile
0.12mm layer, 5 walls, 0% infill
The designer has replied
1
Reply
did it not work even with a bigger brim?
(Edited)
0
Reply
Print Profile
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
1
Reply
Print Profile
Hex 0.2mm layer, 2 walls, 15% infill
1
Reply